Skip to main content

Toshiba glasses-free 3D TV demo: It works, just not very well


First Look: Watch 3D without the glasses




Although Toshiba's glasses-free 3D TV is coming to the U.S. in the next couple of months, and at a price we expect to be north of $10,000, it still has some issues.

Fellow CNET TV reviewer Ty Pendlebury and I both got the chance to check out the set here at CES 2012, and while the head-tracking technology is impressive, and the fact that you can actually see 3D effects without glasses is kind of mind-blowing, the TV we saw definitely felt more like a prototype than a product ready for prime time--especially for that price.

Despite my somewhat positive tone in the video above (blame the excellent appetizers Toshiba was serving), the 3D was definitely inferior to what I've seen on glasses-equipped 3D TVs. I was told to stand in one of three sweet spots, after which the head-tracking technology locked onto my face and the 3D image fused and locked in. At that point I definitely saw 3D, but the effect was shallower and seemmed a bit softer than on any 3D TV with glasses. More annoying were the artifacts, like doubled lines and other cross-talk-like effects I noticed, especially toward the edges of the screen.

I spent most of my 3D viewing time at Toshiba's recommended distance, but Ty moved around a bit more, and he noted that getting closer to the screen made the artifacts even more apparent.

But what really seemed to hurt the experience was the effect's sensitivity to any kind of head movement. Adjusting the position of my eyes relative to the screen, even the barest amount, caused the 3D "fuse" effect to dissolve into a mess of separate lines and take me completely out of the moment. At times the head-tracker would eventually adjust, but it was far from instantaneous. Most humans not made of stone move slightly as they watch TV, and if they're watching this TV such movement would be a constant battle with lost 3D effects.

Toshiba's reps also made sure to point out the set's 4Kx2K 2D resolution by demoing some specialized material. When I didn't immediately react with a "Wow," I was encouraged to approach very close to the screen to appreciate the detail. Of course, I wouldn't recommend anyone watch a 55-inch TV from closer than about 6 feet, at which distance the extra resolution just isn't apparent. And that's assuming that you're watching actual 4K content; there's no benefit when viewing standard 1080p material on a 4K TV at this screen size.
All told, Toshiba's demo proved to me that, even when you don't consider that crazy price, glasses-free TV has a long way to go before it's as enjoyable and practical as 3D TV with glasses.




Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nokia Asha 200 ( Nokia Asha 200 )

Nokia Asha 200 is affordable QWERTY Dual Sim (GSM+GSM) Mobile Phone and offers faster emailing, chatting @ affordable price in India. Nokia 200 Dual Sim Mobile Features: Easily Swap Sim card without switching off the phone Short cut key for SIM card management FM Recording Social networking, email, IM support 2 Megapixel Camera Available in Eight Colors Nokia Asha 200 QWERTY Dual Sim Phone Technical Specifications: Dual GSM Sim Card 900/1800 MHz GPRS/EDGE 2.4” inch QVGA Display screen 10 MB free memory + up to 32GB Memory Card 2MP Camera with 4X Digital Zoom FM recording and Song Capture Bluetooth Powerful Loud Speaker (106 phon) Nokia BL-5J (1430 mAh) Battery Talk time up to 420 Minutes Standby time up to 37 days Dimensions: 115.4 x 61.1 x 14.0 mm Weight: 105 gm Nokia Asha 200 Price in India:  < Rs. 5,000/- INR Nokia 200 Box Includes: Phone, Nokia Charger, Nokia Battery BL-5J and Nokia Stereo Headset WH-102
Post a Comment
Read more

The joy of Microsoft's 'avoid ghetto' GPS patent

Indeed, not so long ago, one lady  sued Google  because the directions its map offered led her (she believed) to be struck by a  car . Now Microsoft has been  granted a patent  that is designed to make its maps more pedestrian-friendly. Somehow, this patent has immediately been dubbed the  "avoid ghetto" feature . Someone seems to have already attempted a ghetto-related mapping exercise, in Ohio. (Credit:  CC JimBobThe Boss/Flickr ) The gist of it seems to be that Microsoft's GPS--which will  reportedly be inserted  into Windows Phones in the future--will use input from more varied and up-to-date sources in order to create suggested routes. Among these sources are crime statistics. Which has led  some to the thought  that this will somehow be an insult to poor neighborhoods. What is unclear, at least from my reading of the patent--which isn't written by anything resembling a human hand or mind--is what kind of crime statistics the...
Post a Comment
Read more

Microsoft says 'see ya' to CES (live blog)

LAS VEGAS--Microsoft has sung its  CES  swan song. The company announced plans last month  to walk away from the Consumer Electronics Show  after a nearly two-decade involvement with the confab and the organization behind it. That made tonight's keynote address from Microsoft Chief Executive Steve Ballmer the beginning of the end. Microsoft  didn't make any major announcements  (other than the fact that Kinect is  coming to Windows on February 1 ). But then, the company has said the timing of the annual confab doesn't generally align with its product news milestones, and that's the key reason it's bailing on the show. Microsoft talked up Windows Phone (its mobile phone operating system that's been getting some praise from the tech press), gave a look at some of the upcoming trim ultrabook computers running  Windows 7 , demoed some previously disclosed features of Windows 8 (which should debut toward the end of 2012), and touted its tile-based Me...
Post a Comment
Read more